We Taste-Tested 50 Flavors to Find the 10 Best Ice Creams in Stores Right Now (2025)

We Taste-Tested 50 Flavors to Find the 10 Best Ice Creams in Stores Right Now (1)

We've been independently researching and testing products for over 120 years. If you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more about our review process.

There’s nothing like a scoop of the best ice cream to round out the evening (or, let’s be honest, to treat yourself in the middle of the day). Creamy, sweet, and packed with flavor, these top pints prove you don’t need to pull out your ice cream maker to enjoy the best ice cream flavors.

We tried over 50 pints (it's a hard job, we know!) from brands like Ben & Jerry's and Talenti to gather the best ice creams in supermarkets. If you’re on the hunt for a classic scoop of vanilla to top off a homemade pie recipe, we’ve picked a store-bought ice cream with serious vanilla flavor and a short ingredient list (no fillers here!). If you're hungry for a a pint full of fudgy swirls and chunks of cookies, chocolate, or fruit, we've picked our fave flavorful pints. We’ve also chosen the best gelato, best chocolate ice cream, a top-notch dairy-free pint, and so much more to satisfy all of your frozen treat cravings. All you need now is a spoon. Get scooping!

1

Best Chocolate Ice Cream

Jeni's Darkest Chocolate Ice Cream

We Taste-Tested 50 Flavors to Find the 10 Best Ice Creams in Stores Right Now (2)

Calling all chocolate lovers. Midwestern ice cream queenJeni Britton Bauer and her team have mastered the intense chocolate flavor without any of the bitterness of dark cocoa powder. This sophisticated pint is perfect on its own.

RELATED:25 Easy and Creative Chocolate Desserts That You Haven't Tried Yet

2

Best Vanilla Frozen Yogurt

Stonyfield Organic Whole Milk Vanilla Frozen Yogurt

We Taste-Tested 50 Flavors to Find the 10 Best Ice Creams in Stores Right Now (3)

Frozen yogurts can be light and icy, but we love Stonyfield's carton for its thick, rich, and custardy texture and intense vanilla flavor.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

3

Best Dairy-Free Option

Talenti Roman Raspberry Sorbetto

We Taste-Tested 50 Flavors to Find the 10 Best Ice Creams in Stores Right Now (4)

If you're looking for a tart and refreshing frozen treat that tastes like legit fruit, grab a spoon and dig into this pint from Talenti. It's full of decadent raspberry flavor (berries are the first ingredient!) and a squeeze oflemon juice.

4

Best Ice Cream With Mint

Ben & Jerry's Mint Chocolate Cookie Ice Cream

We Taste-Tested 50 Flavors to Find the 10 Best Ice Creams in Stores Right Now (5)

We loved this mashup of Cookies 'n' Cream and Mint Chocolate Chip for its spoonfuls loaded with Oreos in each bite. The minty flavor is refreshing but definitelydoesn't overpower the crumbs and big pieces of cookies. We'll take a scoop please!

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

5

Best Coffee Ice Cream

Haagen-Dazs Coffee Ice Cream

We Taste-Tested 50 Flavors to Find the 10 Best Ice Creams in Stores Right Now (6)

Made with only five ingredients, Haagen-Dazs has mastered the decadent coffee flavor and smooth texture of this elegant ice cream.One taster said, "this is the best coffee ice cream I've ever had."

6

Ben & Jerry's Ben & Jerry's Ice Cream Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Core

We Taste-Tested 50 Flavors to Find the 10 Best Ice Creams in Stores Right Now (7)

No need to dig! With thisaddition to thecore lineup,you can find all the chewy cookie goodness at the center of the pint of this seriously nostalgic ice cream.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

7

Graeter's Graeter's Handcrafted French Pot Ice Cream Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip

We Taste-Tested 50 Flavors to Find the 10 Best Ice Creams in Stores Right Now (8)

Of all the black raspberry ice creams we've had, this pint perfectly balances super rich dark chocolate chip bitterness with some seriously fruity flavor. Each bite issweet, creamy, and oh, so delicious.

8

Talenti Talenti Gelato Caramel Cookie Crunch

We Taste-Tested 50 Flavors to Find the 10 Best Ice Creams in Stores Right Now (9)

A simple vanilla base is the perfect canvas for thick and sweet caramel swirls and plenty of cookie pieces. We loved the über-creamytexture of the ice cream. And it's an iconic partner to a warm slice of apple pie.

RELATED:35 Delicious Pie Recipes Anyone Can Make

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

9

Serendipity Humble Pie

We Taste-Tested 50 Flavors to Find the 10 Best Ice Creams in Stores Right Now (10)

The iconic NYC restaurant packed its signature desserts (like their peanut butter pie) into pints. Rich peanut butter ice cream, swirled with peanut butter anddotted with big chocolate chunks and graham cracker pieces, this carton is an epic dessert all on its own.

10

Coolhaus Coolhaus Ice Cream, Awesome, Street Cart Churro Dough

We Taste-Tested 50 Flavors to Find the 10 Best Ice Creams in Stores Right Now (11)

This women-owned business makes the most creative concoctionswe've ever tasted, and we're here for it. Our tasters love this fun combo of rich brown butter ice cream with spiced cookie dough and a bitter chocolate swirled through the pint.

We Taste-Tested 50 Flavors to Find the 10 Best Ice Creams in Stores Right Now (12)

Becca Miller

Associate Editor

Becca Miller (she/her) has been working in the Good Housekeeping Test Kitchen since 2018, where she researches and writes about tasty recipes, food trends and top cooking tools. She graduated from NYU with a liberal arts degree focusing on creative writing. She makes killer scrambled eggs, enjoys a glass of un-oaked chardonnay and takes pride in her love of reality television.

We Taste-Tested 50 Flavors to Find the 10 Best Ice Creams in Stores Right Now (2025)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Gov. Deandrea McKenzie

Last Updated:

Views: 5914

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (46 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Gov. Deandrea McKenzie

Birthday: 2001-01-17

Address: Suite 769 2454 Marsha Coves, Debbieton, MS 95002

Phone: +813077629322

Job: Real-Estate Executive

Hobby: Archery, Metal detecting, Kitesurfing, Genealogy, Kitesurfing, Calligraphy, Roller skating

Introduction: My name is Gov. Deandrea McKenzie, I am a spotless, clean, glamorous, sparkling, adventurous, nice, brainy person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.